Timeless Treasures

Whiskey Creek Consignments redefines the art of consignment

by Robin Howard / photography by holger obenaus

Whiskey Creek Consignments has become a destination for design enthusiasts seeking high-quality, pre-loved furniture and décor. Founded in 2018 by Amy Evitts and Marilyn Morse, this expansive, nearly 7,000-square-foot store has gained a reputation for offering an impressive selection of upscale brands, like Henkel Harris, Theodore Alexander, Bernhardt, Century and Restoration Hardware, alongside unexpected mid-century modern pieces and the occasional fine antique. With a keen eye for quality and a personal touch that sets them apart, Morse and Evitts have built a thriving business that blends sustainability with luxury while fostering a welcoming environment for customers, designers and consigners.

Both women come from backgrounds in professional recruiting, a field that taught them the art of relationships and how to guide people during pivotal moments in their lives. Life transitions led them to explore new career paths that would allow blending their passion for quality craftsmanship with the human connections they have honed during their previous careers.

“When I left the corporate world to manage my parents’ care, I also wanted something part time. I was fascinated with estate sales and came to work at a consignment store, and that’s how I met Marilyn,” Evitts says.

Morse had a similar journey. “I became a full-time caregiver, and when the time came to return to the job market, a friend told me about this opportunity at a consignment store. Amy joined the team shortly thereafter. Little did we know just where that beginning would take us,” she says.

After several years, that store began introducing more and more new furniture into the inventory and moved away from true consignment. “We wanted to give people different choices. There are so many beautiful pieces already out there for people to add to their homes,” Morse says.

And so, in 2018, they took the plunge and opened Whiskey Creek Consignments. Their goal was simple: elevate the consignment experience and offer high-quality, pre-owned furniture and décor that could transform any space. “We wanted to be pure consignment done right,” Evitts says. For the partners that means offering quality pieces that will stand the test of time.

The duo’s expertise ensures that every item in the store is in excellent condition. They scrutinize every item, checking for any flaws, whether cracks in crystal or wear on a sofa or chair. Whiskey Creek’s carefully curated selection is so well-maintained that customers frequently ask if the items are brand-new. “People like to visit; it’s clean, and it doesn’t smell like a consignment store. Everything passes the smell test and the pet hair test. The crystal sparkles. We’re very picky. People notice, and we get compliments on it,” Evitts says

This attention to detail has made Whiskey Creek a favorite among high-end designers from all over. People from Buckhead, North Atlanta, South Carolina, Alabama, even as far as Virginia and Texas, frequent the store looking for quality pieces for their clients. “Designers tell us they like coming here because we consistently have high quality and are very selective about our inventory. They say our prices are very fair. We have unique finds and specialty pieces for their clients that they can’t find elsewhere. They get excited to come in and see what’s new. Many buy a piece and later match it with a client,” Evitts says.

There is a psychology behind consignment that both women have come to understand well over the years. Many of their consigners are going through significant life changes: downsizing, moving into senior living or even dealing with the loss of a loved one. It can be difficult to part with beloved furniture and belongings, and that is where the pair shines. They see themselves as more than business owners; they are there to guide and support their consigners through a sometimes challenging chapter in their lives. “A woman visiting the store said, ‘This is a ministry.’ What a wonderful analogy. It is a ministry. And that woman should know, she’s a pastor. We do a lot a hand-holding. We help consigners get excited, knowing someone new is going to love their pieces,” Morse says.

This compassionate approach has helped the women build strong, lasting customer relationships. “We have found a balance between our consigners and our customers, and we love our relationships with them. We know these people, and they know us. That’s fulfilling,” Morse says.

Prospective consigners can easily send photos of their items via email, which the owners go through daily. Accepted items go through a final inspection in-house. They also make house visits when appropriate. Consigner agreements are for 90 days initially, with only one discount at the 45-day mark. If an item remains unsold at 90 days, it is up to the consigner if they would like to leave it for up to an additional 30 days at a deeper discount of 25%. Consigned items can be tracked through a private web page that makes keeping tabs on inventory easier.

“We love getting photos. You never know when you’ll open a treasure chest. We see a lot of product every day. We focus on high-quality consignment and try to keep a variety of pieces in the store,” Evitts says. The Whiskey Creek team creates an inviting space, and they regularly change displays, offering customers a chance to see how various pieces go together.

One of the owners is in the store every day. “Our team is approachable, right here to help and answer questions. We’re always working on mini vignettes and combining things from all sorts of different design backgrounds so we can show how well things can go together,” Evitts says.

Customers often seek design advice from the duo and the in-store staff, which includes certified designers. One couple spent a year renovating their home and bought pieces from Whiskey Creek throughout the process. Morse says: “When I saw the home, it was a showplace. Even I couldn’t believe how much of it came through our store.”

“People appreciate our honesty, too,” says Evitts. “They’ll bring things from home they want to coordinate with, like fabrics or pillows. As much as we want to sell that rug, if it’s a miss, we’ll say it.”

“We always advise people to surround themselves with what they love,” Morse adds. “Don’t just follow trends.”

For the team at Whiskey Creek, the goal is not so much rapid growth but sustainable, community-centered development. The focus is on the physical store, a crucial part of its identity. “Our model is bricks-and-mortar. You can come in and touch things. We have a great vibe, and lots of people come to decompress with a little retail therapy,” Evitts says.

With their hands-on approach and commitment to quality, Evitts and Morse are poised to continue serving their community. They offer not just beautiful pieces of furniture and décor but a thoughtful, personal experience that transforms the way people shop for their homes. *

Robin Howard is a freelance writer in Charleston. See more of her work at robinhowardwrites.com.

More Information

Whiskey Creek Consignments

4401 Shallowford Road, #170

Roswell, GA 30075

770.741.2273